Carlos Benavides

C DSL Tigers 1

Age 19 R/R 5'10" / 195 lbs ROK HR -8% Svc 0.0 · Ctrl thru 2038

Overview

ROKPROSPECTMiLBFA 2039

ETA2029MLB%0%

Year	Age	Lvl / Team	PA	AVG/OBP/SLG	HR	SB	wRC+	WAR	MLE AVG/OBP/SLG
2025	17	ROKDSL Tigers 2	135	.244/.328/.361	1	3	23	—	.156/.231/.221
2026	18	ROKDSL Tigers 1	138	.283/.425/.453	2	8	60	—	.173/.321/.264
2027PROJ0% MLB	19	MLBDET	248	.207/.277/.297	2	4	64	0.1
2028PROJ34% MLB	20	MLBDET	70	.208/.280/.303	1	1	69	0.0
2029PROJ48% MLB	21	MLBDET	162	.212/.284/.314	2	3	73	0.1

Next 3 projected WAR 0.3Projected rows: MLB playing time only, park and league context applied.

ContractESTIMATED

Control thru2038Service0.0First FA2039

2027MiLB2028MiLB2029MiLB2030MiLB2031MiLB2032MiLB2033Pre-Arb$0.9M2034Pre-Arb$1.0M+4

Skills · percentileMiLB Statcast 2026 Rk

wOBA76

ISO74

wRC+57

Speed57

Whiff%52

K%47

Career WAR0 WAR median (P10 0 / P90 0, comp-based) · star 0% · didn't stick 100%

CompsCooper Pratt (age 19) · Gilberto Celestino (age 19) · Jacob Amaya (age 19)

2027 FULL-SEASON PROJECTIONpark-neutral Marcel · 115 proj PA

wRC+†64

AVG/OBP/SLG.206 / .275 / .294

PA115

HR1

K%27

BB%6

ISO89

MLB%0%

Value2027 · WAR

━ projected WAR━ paid WAR ($/8M) surplus deficit+$22M ctrl surplus

Tools · ContractCON 46 / POW 37

Toolsscout grade

CONTACT46

scouting grade only

POWER37

scouting grade only

EYE47

scouting grade only

SPEED55

scouting grade only

Contract ESTIMATED · service-time + WAR-based estimator (needs verification)

Status MiLB

MLB Debut 2033

Service 0 yrs (est)

Team Control Through 2038

First FA Year 2039

Year	Status	Salary	Proj WAR	Value	Surplus
2027	MiLB	still in minors · estimated debut 2033
2028	MiLB	still in minors · estimated debut 2033
2029	MiLB	still in minors · estimated debut 2033
2030	MiLB	still in minors · estimated debut 2033
2031	MiLB	still in minors · estimated debut 2033
2032	MiLB	still in minors · estimated debut 2033
2033	Pre-Arb	$0.9M	+0.6	$2M	+$1M
2034	Pre-Arb	$1.0M	+0.6	$1M	+$1.0M
2035	Pre-Arb	$1.0M	+0.5	$1M	+$0.7M
2036	Arb-1	$2M	+0.4	$0.8M	+$0.0M
2037	Arb-2	$3M	+0.3	$0.6M	+$0.0M (cut)
2038	Arb-3	$2M	+0.1	$0.2M	+$0.0M (cut)
Totals		$5M		$6M	+$3M

Career Stats + Projections

Real MLB stats plus park-adjusted projections — this season (so far / rest / full), then future seasons and career totals.

show model inputsbasis chips: RAW = as recorded · CTX = with park/league context · A+C = actual + context combined · MLE = level/park-neutral

Methodology▸ how these numbers are built

All seasons translated to park-neutral MLB-equivalent (MLE) and combined per year. 2027 = actual YTD + projected ROS + total. 2028+ via Advanced Marcel + aging curve. Catcher framing: only 2027 Statcast framing is modeled (Baseball Savant server-caches the leaderboard to the current season); prior-year framing is unmodeled — projections for established framers may run below FG-DC by 1-3 WAR.

Year	Age	Lvl	Team	MLB%	PA	AB	H	2B	3B	HR	BB	SO	HBP	SB	CS	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	ISO	BABIP	K%	BB%	wOBA	wRC+	BAT	RUN	FLD	POS	REP	WAR
▸ Career — actual stats, one row per stint (as recorded, no adjustments)
2025	17	ROK	DSL Tigers 2	—	135	119	29	9	1	1	11	30	4	3	2	244	328	361	690	118	315	22	8	312	23	—	—	—	—	—	—
2026	18	ROK	DSL Tigers 1	—	138	106	30	12	0	2	11	30	16	8	1	283	425	453	878	170	359	22	8	388	60	—	—	—	—	—	—
▸ Career — adjusted (every ACTUAL line translated to park/league-neutral MLB equivalents)
2025	17	ROK MLE	DSL Tigers 2	—	135	122	19	6	1	0	8	37	4	3	2	156	231	221	453	66	209	27	6	202	23	—	—	—	—	—	—
2026	18	ROK MLE	DSL Tigers 1	—	138	110	19	7	0	1	8	37	16	8	1	173	321	264	585	91	217	27	6	257	60	—	—	—	—	—	—
2025	17	ROK MLE	DSL Tigers 2	—	135	122	19	6	1	0	8	37	4	3	2	156	231	221	453	66	221	27	6	202	23	—	—	—	—	—	—
2025	17	ROK RAW	DSL Tigers 2	—	135	119	29	9	1	1	11	30	4	3	2	244	328	361	690	118	315	22	8	312	23	—	—	—	—	—	—
2026	18	ROK MLE	DSL Tigers 1	—	138	110	19	7	0	1	8	37	16	8	1	173	321	264	585	91	237	27	6	257	60	—	—	—	—	—	—
2026	18	ROK RAW	DSL Tigers 1	—	138	106	30	12	0	2	11	30	16	8	1	283	425	453	878	170	359	22	8	388	60	—	—	—	—	—	—
2025	17	ROK MLE	DSL Tigers 2	—	135	122	19	6	1	0	8	37	4	3	2	156	231	221	453	66	209	27	6	202	23	—	—	—	—	—	—
2026	18	ROK MLE	DSL Tigers 1	—	138	113	19	7	0	1	8	37	16	8	1	168	321	257	578	88	217	27	6	257	60	—	—	—	—	—	—
▸ Model inputs — neutral MLE (past 3 seasons)
2025	17	ROK MLE	DSL Tigers 2	—	135	122	19	6	1	0	8	37	4	3	2	156	231	221	453	66	209	27	6	202	23	—	—	—	—	—	—
2026	18	ROK MLE	DSL Tigers 1	—	138	113	19	7	0	1	8	37	16	8	1	168	321	257	578	88	217	27	6	257	60	—	—	—	—	—	—
▸ 2027 season
▸ 2027 — full MLE projection (neutral park, full availability)
2027	19	MLB MLE	DET	0%	248	224	46	10	2	2	16	67	6	4	1	207	277	297	574	89	282	27	6	262	64	-11	+0	+0	+4	+5	0.1
▸ Career projection (2028+) — MLB context, MLB playing time (PA × MLB%)
2028	20	MLB MLE	DET	34%	203	183	39	9	1	2	13	54	5	4	1	212	283	310	592	98	284	27	6	270	69	-8	+0	+0	+4	+4	0.1
2029	21	MLB MLE	DET	48%	335	302	64	14	2	4	22	88	8	7	2	215	287	320	608	105	286	26	7	276	73	-11	+1	+0	+6	+7	0.3
2030	22	MLB MLE	DET	54%	431	389	84	18	3	6	29	112	10	9	3	219	291	330	620	111	287	26	7	281	76	-12	+1	+0	+8	+9	0.6
2031	23	MLB MLE	DET	57%	495	446	98	21	3	8	34	127	12	11	3	221	293	337	631	116	288	26	7	285	79	-12	+1	+0	+9	+11	0.8
2032	24	MLB MLE	DET	57%	520	467	104	22	3	9	36	132	12	11	3	224	296	343	639	120	289	25	7	288	81	-12	+1	+0	+9	+11	1.0
2033	25	MLB MLE	DET	57%	520	467	104	22	3	9	36	132	12	11	3	224	296	344	641	121	289	25	7	289	82	-11	+1	+0	+9	+11	1.0
2034	26	MLB MLE	DET	56%	520	467	104	22	3	9	36	132	12	11	4	224	296	345	641	121	289	25	7	289	82	-11	+1	+0	+9	+11	1.0
2035	27	MLB MLE	DET	55%	520	467	104	22	3	9	36	133	12	11	4	223	295	342	637	119	288	26	7	288	81	-12	+1	+0	+9	+11	0.9
2036	28	MLB MLE	DET	55%	520	467	104	22	3	9	36	134	12	10	4	221	293	337	630	117	287	26	7	285	79	-13	+0	-1	+9	+11	0.7
2037	29	MLB MLE	DET	58%	520	468	102	22	3	8	36	136	11	9	4	218	290	331	621	113	286	26	7	281	76	-15	+0	-1	+9	+11	0.5
2038	30	MLB MLE	DET	60%	520	468	101	21	3	8	36	137	11	9	4	215	286	323	610	108	284	26	7	277	73	-17	+0	-2	+9	+11	0.2
2039	31	MLB MLE	DET	62%	504	454	96	20	3	7	34	135	11	7	5	211	281	313	595	102	280	27	7	270	69	-18	-1	-3	+9	+11	-0.2
2028	20	MLB CTX	DET	34%	70	63	13	3	0	1	5	19	2	1	0	208	280	303	583	95	280	27	7	266	69	-3	+0	+0	+1	+2	0.0
2029	21	MLB CTX	DET	48%	162	146	31	7	1	2	11	42	4	3	1	212	284	314	598	102	281	26	7	272	73	-5	+0	+0	+3	+4	0.1
2030	22	MLB CTX	DET	54%	234	210	45	10	1	3	16	61	6	5	2	215	287	322	610	108	282	26	7	277	76	-7	+0	+0	+4	+5	0.3
2031	23	MLB CTX	DET	57%	280	252	55	12	2	4	19	72	7	6	2	218	290	330	620	112	283	26	7	281	79	-7	+0	+0	+5	+6	0.5
2032	24	MLB CTX	DET	57%	294	265	58	12	2	5	20	75	7	6	2	220	292	336	628	116	284	26	7	284	81	-7	+0	+0	+5	+6	0.6
2033	25	MLB CTX	DET	57%	294	265	58	12	2	5	20	75	7	6	2	220	293	337	629	117	284	26	7	285	82	-6	+0	+0	+5	+6	0.6
2034	26	MLB CTX	DET	56%	294	265	58	12	2	5	20	75	7	6	2	220	293	337	630	117	284	26	7	285	82	-6	+0	+0	+5	+6	0.6
2035	27	MLB CTX	DET	55%	288	259	57	12	2	5	20	74	7	6	2	219	292	334	626	116	283	26	7	283	81	-7	+0	+0	+5	+6	0.5
2036	28	MLB CTX	DET	55%	285	257	57	12	2	5	20	74	6	6	2	217	290	330	619	113	282	26	7	281	79	-7	+0	-0	+5	+6	0.4
2037	29	MLB CTX	DET	58%	302	271	59	12	2	5	21	79	7	6	2	215	287	324	610	109	281	26	7	277	76	-8	+0	-1	+5	+7	0.3
2038	30	MLB CTX	DET	60%	313	282	61	13	2	5	21	83	7	5	2	212	283	316	599	105	279	27	7	272	73	-10	+0	-1	+6	+7	0.1
2039	31	MLB CTX	DET	62%	311	280	58	12	2	4	21	83	7	5	3	207	278	307	585	99	276	27	7	266	69	-11	-0	-2	+6	+7	-0.1
▸ Career Totals
▸ Career totals — MLB only (actual + projected)
Career	—	A+C		—	3127	2815	610	129	20	49	214	812	74	61	22	217	289	329	618	112	285	26	7	278	75	-84	+3	-4	+56	+68	3.9
/ 162G	—	A+C		—	650	585	127	27	4	10	44	169	15	13	5	217	288	328	617	111	286	26	7	278	75	-17	+1	-1	+12	+14	0.8
Career	—	MLE		—	5996	5381	1164	253	35	90	407	1557	151	123	44	216	290	327	616	110	285	26	7	280	75	-156	+6	-7	+102	+124	7.0
/ 162G	—	MLE		—	650	583	126	27	4	10	44	169	16	13	5	216	289	328	616	111	284	26	7	280	75	-18	+1	-1	+12	+14	0.8

PLAYER · career totals + /162 games	162s	PA	HR	SB	AVG	OBP	SLG	POS	FLD	WAR	JAWS
#1Tucker Barnhartlast yr '24 career totals — 11 seasons, 3,088 PA	4.7	3,088	53	8	241	318	351	+55	+57	16.5	16.1
/162	664	11	2	+11.9	+12.3	3.6	pk7: 16
#2Rod Barajaslast yr '12 career totals — 12 seasons, 3,753 PA	5.7	3,753	134	2	235	284	407	+60	+30	15.8	16.0
/162	664	24	0	+10.7	+5.3	2.8	pk7: 16
#3Jacob Stallingslast yr '25 career totals — 7 seasons, 1,850 PA	2.8	1,850	33	0	229	310	340	+33	+50	10.3	10.3
/162	664	12	0	+11.9	+17.9	3.7	pk7: 10
#4Buck Rodgers'61-'69 * career totals — 9 seasons, 3,353 PA	5.0	3,353	31	17	239*	294*	339*	+60	+0	6.4	6.5
/162	664	6	3	+11.8	+0.0	1.3	pk7: 7
#5Fred Kendall'69-'80 * career totals — 8 seasons, 2,823 PA	4.3	2,823	31	5	231*	283*	340*	+48	+1	5.0	5.9
/162	664	7	1	+11.2	+0.1	1.2	pk7: 7
OGOGILVIE CAREER PROJECTION career totals — every cell rolls up across 8 projected seasons	4.9	3,243	52	64	220	288	333	+58	+32	6.3	5.6
/162	664	11	13	+11.9	+6.6	1.3	pk7: 5
#6Al Spohrer'28-'35 * career totals — 8 seasons, 2,383 PA	3.6	2,383	6	13	230*	282*	337*	+43	+0	2.6	2.9
/162	664	2	4	+11.9	+0.0	0.7	pk7: 3

Career Path Comps

What happened to players with a similar stat profile at this age · Y-axis: wRC+ (100 = league avg, 150 = elite, 80 = below) · Bands: P10–P90 outer, P25–P75 inner · Gold: OGILVIE projection

		Scouting				At Match Age									Next 3 Yrs									Peak 3 Yrs
Comp	Age	HIT	PWR	SPD	EYE	AVG/OBP/SLG	ISO	BABIP	HR	SB	K%	BB%	wRC+	WAR	AVG/OBP/SLG	ISO	BABIP	HR	SB	K%	BB%	wRC+	WAR	AVG/OBP/SLG	ISO	BABIP	HR	SB	K%	BB%	wRC+	WAR
Carlos Benavides (OGILVIE)	19	41→46	32→37	50→55	47	206/275/294	89	282	1	2	27%	6%	64	-0.3	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—
✕Cooper Pratt 2024 · A	19	49→52	37→40	54→55	41	226/288/305	78	332	4	11	31%	6%	70	-0.9	228/299/323	95	293	8	23	23%	8%	78	-0.3	229/306/324	95	284	8	29	21%	9%	81	-0.1
✕Gilberto Celestino 2018 · A	19	43→53	39→45	53→55	43	206/263/292	86	288	6	12	30%	7%	57	-1.8	220/271/312	92	287	7	10	24%	6%	65	-1.2	239/317/316	76	309	5	10	22%	9%	81	-0.0
✕Jacob Amaya 2018 · A	19	44→47	39→45	48→45	46	211/280/295	84	285	6	8	27%	8%	65	-1.2	225/304/318	93	298	6	8	24%	10%	79	-0.2	218/291/330	112	279	11	6	25%	9%	75	-0.4
✕Jonathan Ornelas 2019 · A	19	46→56	40→45	53→50	44	219/282/318	99	308	7	14	30%	8%	70	-0.8	209/265/301	92	294	7	10	29%	6%	60	-1.6	251/312/338	87	342	8	12	27%	7%	83	+0.1
✕Jett Williams 2023 · A	19	45→48	41→50	56→55	44	216/287/317	101	287	8	14	26%	7%	73	-0.6	213/317/337	124	303	10	23	29%	12%	90	+0.6	212/316/350	138	296	11	26	29%	12%	89	+0.4
✕Miguel Palma 2021 · A	19	40	39→45	48→40	45	193/281/280	88	261	6	11	27%	7%	63	-1.3	215/293/337	122	281	13	5	27%	8%	80	-0.1	217/284/341	124	274	15	2	26%	7%	76	-0.2
✕Andrés Nolaya 2024 · A	19	39	36→45	47→50	46	183/256/246	64	263	3	12	30%	8%	45	-2.7	196/270/269	73	284	4	17	30%	8%	55	-1.9	201/281/282	81	280	7	21	28%	8%	61	-0.5
✕Jefferson Rojas 2024 · A	19	45→48	41→50	52→50	43	221/283/322	101	279	9	15	24%	6%	72	-0.7	222/283/337	115	269	12	16	21%	7%	76	-0.4	225/287/358	133	263	15	18	21%	7%	81	-0.1
✕Brennen Davis 2019 · A	19	48→43	36→50	51→45	46	221/300/290	68	306	3	12	26%	8%	72	-0.7	233/303/375	142	314	15	8	29%	7%	93	+0.8	188/287/362	173	236	23	4	30%	8%	83	+0.0
✕Jorge Alcantara 2011 · A	19	45	41→45	51→50	43	215/278/316	101	296	7	11	29%	7%	68	-1.0	197/266/293	96	297	7	13	33%	8%	59	-1.6	143/221/238	95	216	5	25	34%	8%	30	-1.0
✕Manuel Palencia 2022 · A	19	45	35→40	48→40	47	210/268/274	64	254	2	9	18%	6%	55	-1.9	216/272/269	53	248	1	6	13%	7%	55	-1.9	224/277/259	35	251	0	4	10%	6%	51	-0.5
✕Braulio Vasquez 2018 · A	19	47	34→40	52→65	44	215/281/268	53	304	1	15	28%	7%	59	-1.7	198/257/271	73	304	5	8	34%	6%	51	-2.3	189/270/268	79	286	5	32	33%	8%	53	-0.8
✕José Mejía 2024 · A	18	47→45	37→40	52→50	50	220/299/296	76	279	4	16	21%	8%	72	-0.7	209/295/292	83	249	5	20	17%	9%	70	-0.8	206/298/295	89	251	6	19	19%	10%	70	-0.4
✕Adrian De Leon 2023 · A	19	41	37→40	47→45	46	194/269/265	72	268	4	7	28%	8%	55	-2.0	194/292/269	75	320	6	5	37%	9%	65	-1.2	160/270/224	63	280	5	3	40%	10%	47	-1.1
✕Adrián Sugastey 2022 · A	19	51	37→40	49→40	42	244/287/314	70	318	5	5	24%	5%	71	-0.8	222/270/304	82	282	6	3	22%	5%	62	-1.4	225/265/311	86	256	8	3	15%	4%	60	-0.7
✕Jeremy Arocho 2018 · A	19	43→44	38→30	53→60	41	204/261/287	83	286	4	12	29%	6%	55	-1.9	223/282/290	67	291	2	11	22%	7%	64	-1.3	230/324/274	45	312	0	26	23%	11%	74	-0.3
✕Carlos Cauro 2024 · A	19	40	40	46→45	49	193/286/282	89	274	7	4	30%	10%	65	-1.2	204/280/311	107	300	11	5	33%	8%	70	-0.9	198/280/293	95	285	12	5	32%	8%	65	-0.4
✕Jose Escobar 2024 · A	19	46→56	39→40	55→45	42	220/276/306	85	277	6	14	22%	5%	65	-1.2	227/297/326	99	296	8	9	24%	7%	78	-0.3	236/304/334	98	303	8	8	23%	7%	80	-0.1
✕Jose Paez 2013 · A	19	44	38→45	50	46	210/269/292	82	266	4	13	22%	6%	59	-1.6	202/248/279	77	299	4	11	32%	5%	49	-2.4	176/218/244	68	280	3	12	36%	4%	25	-1.1
✕Dariel Lopez 2021 · A	19	45→48	37→50	50→45	44	213/269/293	80	271	4	8	22%	6%	60	-1.6	228/275/336	108	332	11	4	33%	5%	72	-0.7	230/276/341	110	334	13	3	34%	5%	71	-0.6

Carlos Benavides

Career Stats + Projections

Career Comps

Career Path Comps