Carlos BenavidesC DSL Tigers 1
Age 18 R/R 5'10" / 195 lbs ROK HR -8% Svc 0.0 · Ctrl thru 2037
2026 ROS PROJECTION95 act + 63 ros · stats below = ROS only
wRC+†60
AVG/OBP/SLG.192 / .268 / .279
PA63
HR1
K%28
BB%6
BABIP261
ISO87
MLB%0%
Value2026 · WAR
BAT: -6.8 runs (wOBA-derived runs vs avg)-7BATRUN: +1.0 runs (SB/CS + UBR baserunning)+1RUNFLD: +0.0 runs (Defensive runs vs avg)+0FLDPOS: +2.8 runs (Positional adjustment)+3POSREP: +4.5 runs (Replacement-level credit)+4REPTotal WAR: +0.20+0.2WAR
0.01.02.00.20.61.01.31.41.41.41.41.51.41.2+$87M ctrl surplus26272829303132333435
━ projected WAR━ paid WAR ($/8M) surplus deficit
Tools · ContractCON 36 / POW 39
Toolsscout grade
CONTACT36
scouting grade only
POWER39
scouting grade only
EYE47
scouting grade only
SPEED54
scouting grade only
Contract ESTIMATED · service-time + WAR-based estimator (needs verification)
Status   MiLB
MLB Debut   2032
Service   0 yrs (est)
Team Control Through   2037
First FA Year   2038
YearStatusSalary Proj WAR Value Surplus
2026MiLBstill in minors · estimated debut 2032
2027MiLBstill in minors · estimated debut 2032
2028MiLBstill in minors · estimated debut 2032
2029MiLBstill in minors · estimated debut 2032
2030MiLBstill in minors · estimated debut 2032
2031MiLBstill in minors · estimated debut 2032
2032Pre-Arb$0.9M+1.4$7M+$7M
2033Pre-Arb$1.0M+1.4$7M+$6M
2034Pre-Arb$1.0M+1.4$6M+$6M
2035Arb-1$3M+1.5$6M+$5M
2036Arb-2$4M+1.4$5M+$4M
2037Arb-3$5M+1.2$4M+$2M
Totals $16M $35M +$30M

Career Stats + Projections

Viewactual = stats as recorded (prior seasons combined) + projected real-world MLB lines · MLE = level/park-neutral translations
Methodology▸ how these numbers are built

All seasons translated to park-neutral MLB-equivalent (MLE) and combined per year. 2026 = actual YTD + projected ROS + total. 2027+ via Advanced Marcel + aging curve. Catcher framing: only 2026 Statcast framing is modeled (Baseball Savant server-caches the leaderboard to the current season); prior-year framing is unmodeled — projections for established framers may run below FG-DC by 1-3 WAR.

YearAge LvlTeam MLB% PAAB H2B3BHR BBSOHBP SBCS AVGOBPSLGOPS ISOBABIP K%BB% wOBAwRC+ BATRUNFLDPOSREP WAR
202517 ROKDSL Tigers 2 — 135123 22611 7444 32 179246268515 89266 335 220 27 — — — — — —
202517 ROKDSL Tigers 2 — 135119 29911 11304 32 244328361690 118315 228 312 97 — — — — — —
▸ 2026 Season (ACT · ROS-MLE · ROS-CTX · FULL)
YTD18 ROKDET — 9576 14302 62910 61 184326303629 118250 316 268 63 -4 +1 +0 +2 +3 0.1
YTD18 ROKDET — 9572 18502 102010 61 250413403816 153302 2111 367 139 +4 +1 +0 +2 +3 1.0
ROS18 ROKDET 0% 6357 11201 4182 20 192268279547 87270 286 264 60 -3 +0 +0 +1 +2 0.1
ROS18 MLBDET 0% 01 0000 000 00 —— 266 —— 234 37 — — +0 +0 — —
FULL18 ROKDET — 9577 14302 62910 61 182326299625 117245 316 268 63 -4 +1 +0 +2 +3 0.1
TOT18 ROKDET — 158133 25503 104712 81 188303292595 105255 306 267 62 -7 +1 +0 +3 +4 0.2
▸ 2027+ Projections   WITH CONTEXT · MLB TIME ONLY ⓘ
202719 MLBDET 34% 203181 37813 14556 41 204284309593 105273 277 272 66 -8 +0 +0 +4 +6 0.2
202820 MLBDET 48% 339302 641326 249110 72 212292328619 116276 277 280 72 -11 +1 +0 +6 +10 0.6
202921 MLBDET 54% 443395 831728 3211713 92 210291324615 114278 267 285 76 -12 +1 +0 +8 +13 1.0
203022 MLBDET 57% 516459 9920310 3713515 113 216295338633 122279 267 288 79 -12 +1 +0 +9 +15 1.3
203123 MLBDET 58% 520462 10020310 3813515 113 216297338635 121280 267 290 80 -12 +1 +0 +9 +15 1.4
203224 MLBDET 61% 520461 10120311 3813516 113 219301347648 128281 267 291 81 -11 +1 +0 +9 +15 1.4
203325 MLBDET 63% 520461 10120311 3813416 113 219301347648 128281 267 292 81 -11 +1 +0 +9 +15 1.4
203426 MLBDET 64% 520461 10120311 3813416 113 219301347648 128281 267 292 82 -11 +1 +0 +9 +15 1.4
203527 MLBDET 65% 520460 10120311 3913516 113 220303348651 128281 268 292 82 -11 +1 +0 +9 +15 1.5
203628 MLBDET 65% 520460 10120311 3913516 112 220303348651 128280 268 291 81 -11 +1 -1 +9 +15 1.4
203729 MLBDET 65% 520461 9920310 3913615 102 215297336633 121279 268 289 79 -12 +1 -1 +9 +15 1.2
203830 MLBDET 65% 520461 9820210 3913815 102 213295330625 117278 278 286 77 -13 +1 -2 +9 +15 1.0
203931 MLBDET 65% 504446 931929 3813515 102 209293321613 112275 278 282 74 -15 +1 -3 +9 +14 0.7
204032 MLBDET 65% 489435 901829 3713314 92 207290320610 113272 278 277 70 -17 +1 -4 +9 +14 0.4
204133 MLBDET 65% 473421 841628 3513114 82 200283304587 105268 287 270 65 -19 +1 -4 +8 +13 -0.0
204234 MLBDET 60% 435388 751427 3212312 72 193275294569 101262 287 262 58 -20 +1 -5 +8 +12 -0.5
202719 MLBDET 34% 7063 13301 5192 10 206286302587 95269 277 245 46 -4 +0 +0 +1 +2 -0.1
202820 MLBDET 48% 164147 30613 11445 31 204282320602 116272 277 253 52 -9 +0 +0 +3 +5 -0.1
202921 MLBDET 54% 240214 44914 17637 51 206286313599 107274 267 258 56 -12 +1 +0 +4 +7 -0.0
203022 MLBDET 57% 292260 561126 21769 61 215297342639 127275 267 262 58 -14 +1 +0 +5 +8 0.1
203123 MLBDET 58% 299266 571126 22789 61 214296338635 124276 267 263 60 -14 +1 +0 +5 +8 0.1
203224 MLBDET 61% 317282 601226 23829 72 213293333626 121276 267 265 61 -14 +1 +0 +6 +9 0.1
203325 MLBDET 63% 326289 621226 248410 72 215297332629 118276 267 265 61 -14 +1 +0 +6 +9 0.1
203426 MLBDET 64% 332295 641327 248610 72 217298346644 129276 267 265 61 -15 +1 +0 +6 +9 0.1
203527 MLBDET 65% 338300 651327 258810 72 217299343642 127276 267 265 61 -15 +1 +0 +6 +10 0.1
203628 MLBDET 65% 338300 651327 258810 72 217299343642 127275 267 264 61 -15 +1 -0 +6 +10 0.1
203729 MLBDET 65% 338299 641326 268910 72 214299331630 117274 268 263 59 -16 +1 -1 +6 +10 -0.0
203830 MLBDET 65% 338299 621226 269010 72 207293321614 114273 278 260 57 -16 +1 -1 +6 +10 -0.2
203931 MLBDET 65% 328290 611226 258810 61 210295328623 117271 278 256 54 -17 +1 -2 +6 +9 -0.3
204032 MLBDET 65% 318282 561115 24869 61 199283298580 99267 278 251 50 -18 +1 -2 +6 +9 -0.5
204133 MLBDET 65% 307272 531015 23859 51 195280294574 99263 287 245 45 -19 +1 -3 +5 +9 -0.7
204234 MLBDET 60% 263233 44814 20758 41 189276283559 94257 298 237 39 -18 +0 -3 +5 +7 -0.9
▸ Career Totals
Career— — 46084092 8561692585 3411221137 9122 209292325617 116274 267 258 56 -229 +9 -13 +82 +131 -2.0
/ 162G— — 650577 12124412 4817219 133 210292328619 118275 267 258 56 -32 +1 -2 +12 +18 -0.3
Career— — 77606894 146029340147 5682064230 15639 212294330623 118278 277 283 75 -220 +16 -20 +139 +220 13.7
/ 162G— — 650577 12225312 4817319 133 211293328621 116278 277 283 75 -18 +1 -2 +12 +18 1.2

Historical Stats — Raw (Per Stint)

Actual MLB + MiLB stats as they happened, one row per stint at each level. Use this to see what really got recorded; the table above shows MLB-equivalent translations + projections.

YearAge LvlTeam MLB% PAAB H2B3BHR BBSOHBP SBCS AVGOBPSLGOPS ISOBABIP K%BB% wOBAwRC+ BATRUNFLDPOSREP WAR
202517 ROKDSL Tigers 2 — 135119 29911 11304 32 244328361690 118315 228 312 97 -0 -0 — — +4 0.3

Career Comps

Retired MLB careers whose totals most resemble what we're projecting for this player. Top row of each card is career totals; bottom row is per-162-game rates. Pool: 727 completed hitter careers (2000-2024).

PLAYER · career totals + /162 gamesYRSPAHRSBAVGOBPSLGPOSFLDWARJAWS
#1Tucker Barnhartlast yr '24
career totals — 11 seasons, 3,088 PA
113,088538241318351+55+5716.616.1
/162664112+11.9+12.33.6pk7: 16
#2Rod Barajaslast yr '12
career totals — 12 seasons, 3,753 PA
123,7531342235284407+60+3015.816.0
/162664240+10.7+5.32.8pk7: 16
#3John Bucklast yr '14
career totals — 11 seasons, 4,009 PA
114,0091346234301398+72+716.915.7
/162664221+11.9+1.22.8pk7: 14
#4Brad Ausmuslast yr '10
career totals — 11 seasons, 4,296 PA
114,2963939244319326+39+4312.412.0
/16266466+6.1+6.61.9pk7: 12
#5Bobby Crosbylast yr '10
career totals — 7 seasons, 2,832 PA
72,8326234238305374+28+3311.611.6
/162664158+6.7+7.72.7pk7: 12
#6Danny Espinosalast yr '17
career totals — 8 seasons, 3,267 PA
83,2679864221297378+16+3611.011.4
/1626642013+3.2+7.32.2pk7: 12
OGOGILVIE CAREER PROJECTION
career totals — every cell rolls up across 11 projected seasons
114,7219094213292332+84+449.27.7
/1626641313+11.9+6.21.3pk7: 6

Career Path Comps

What happened to players with a similar stat profile at this age · Y-axis: wRC+ (100 = league avg, 150 = elite, 80 = below) · Bands: P10–P90 outer, P25–P75 inner · Gold: OGILVIE projection

Scouting At Match Age Next 3 Yrs Peak 3 Yrs
Comp Age HIT PWR SPD EYE AVG/OBP/SLG ISOBABIP HRSB K%BB% wRC+WAR AVG/OBP/SLG ISOBABIP HRSB K%BB% wRC+WAR AVG/OBP/SLG ISOBABIP HRSB K%BB% wRC+WAR
Carlos Benavides (OGILVIE) 18 31→36 34→39 49→54 47 188/303/292 105255 38 30% 6% 62 +0.2 ————————— —————————
✕Kelvin Hidalgo
2023 · A 		18 42→39 40→45 50→55 44 204/266/298 94269 613 25% 6% 55 -1.4 206/263/306 100292 917 31% 6% 56 -1.3 196/248/2858929182334%5%42-1.3
✕Victor Rodrigues
2023 · A 		18 41 38→30 49→50 44 197/261/279 83254 57 24% 6% 49 -1.8 211/290/283 72267 59 21% 9% 62 -0.9 219/316/2715227241019%11%68-0.2
✕Denzer Guzman
2023 · A 		19 38→36 40→45 47→50 42 190/245/284 93260 79 29% 6% 43 -2.2 187/246/287 100286 98 36% 7% 43 -2.2 205/268/331127286151232%7%61-0.7
✕Hector Garcia
2008 · A 		18 38 40→45 49→40 41 188/237/274 86249 76 27% 6% 36 -2.7 212/263/289 77269 64 22% 6% 51 -1.7 222/269/309872707120%5%56-0.4
✕Raul Juarez
2016 · A 		18 37 38→45 45→40 37 182/242/262 80251 57 29% 4% 36 -2.7 207/265/290 83274 75 26% 5% 53 -1.5 203/259/274712668326%4%44-0.5
✕Yasmil Bucce
2023 · A 		18 41 40→45 49→30 44 198/265/288 89272 75 29% 7% 53 -1.5 202/288/300 98309 84 34% 10% 66 -0.6 205/306/33412832513237%11%79+0.2
✕Ricardo Cova
2022 · A 		18 44 38→50 47→55 44 212/278/287 75273 69 24% 6% 57 -1.2 209/268/294 85323 715 35% 6% 55 -1.4 235/286/365130286142022%5%78+0.1
✕Jesus Galiz
2022 · A 		18 40 36→45 51→40 40 190/241/256 66253 37 25% 5% 33 -2.9 200/258/308 108293 104 33% 6% 55 -1.4 189/250/287982958237%6%45-1.0
✕Yordany De Los Santos
2023 · A 		18 42→39 36→45 51→60 46 193/275/265 72282 313 30% 9% 51 -1.7 203/273/292 89313 723 34% 8% 56 -1.3 206/260/333127301143535%6%58-0.7
✕Amador Arias
2019 · A 		18 34 39→45 48→50 45 170/242/253 83225 713 27% 7% 34 -2.8 186/256/285 99277 912 34% 7% 48 -1.9 118/203/228110217141150%8%10-1.7
✕Janelfry Zorrilla
2010 · A 		19 38 38→45 51→50 38 189/234/265 77255 613 28% 4% 33 -2.9 216/275/340 124268 1212 23% 6% 70 -0.3 221/275/34011927913925%5%68-0.2
✕Hidekel Abreu
2016 · A 		18 42 36→40 49→50 45 199/266/263 64280 38 28% 8% 46 -2.0 223/284/304 81293 510 24% 7% 63 -0.8 237/299/3178030061221%8%68-0.2
✕Mariel Bautista
2016 · A 		18 41→34 38→45 50 40 197/258/282 85286 58 31% 6% 48 -1.9 226/275/318 92287 614 22% 5% 63 -0.8 239/283/34010128981819%4%70-0.1
✕Ravel Santana
2010 · A 		18 39 42→50 48→55 44 192/269/294 102269 109 31% 8% 56 -1.3 219/288/360 141283 1615 27% 8% 81 +0.4 220/291/383163271202026%8%85+0.3
✕Daniel Santos
2017 · A 		18 40 35→45 51→40 43 188/256/247 59280 38 32% 8% 37 -2.6 189/258/268 79267 56 29% 6% 44 -2.1 173/243/251782455430%6%33-0.8
✕Richard Rodriguez
2012 · A 		19 39 36→30 48→50 45 186/255/247 61260 312 28% 8% 37 -2.6 210/266/251 41261 114 19% 7% 42 -2.3 233/291/2542027801615%7%50-0.6
✕Jose Astudillo
2022 · A 		18 43 37→30 52→50 46 204/257/278 73249 39 19% 6% 46 -2.0 230/283/304 74270 315 15% 6% 63 -0.9 293/336/3909732081910%4%104+0.6
✕Marco Guzman
2013 · A 		18 37 35→45 47→50 47 176/257/242 66244 28 26% 8% 38 -2.6 198/263/278 80251 47 22% 8% 49 -1.8 227/264/3321052916823%5%60-0.3
✕Jose Paez
2012 · A 		18 36 36→45 51→50 41 173/241/239 66265 416 34% 7% 30 -3.1 220/268/311 91310 512 29% 5% 58 -1.2 226/270/3199331941229%5%56-0.4
✕Rafael Herrera
2019 · A 		18 43 35→40 52→50 45 200/267/266 67269 212 25% 7% 47 -1.9 218/286/298 80291 412 24% 8% 63 -0.8 229/304/3108129741722%9%71-0.1